Petg vs pla reddit. It has a lower melting point and is biodegradable.

Petg vs pla reddit There is no standard what the additive(s) are. Since its recommended to print PLA with the door and top lid opened: Do I have to fear having trouble printing PLA with the top glass lid closed? PLA+ is just PLA with additives. The only reason I use PETG now is for structural or large parts that need good inter-layer adhesion. But PETG costs that tad more and is that tad less fun to print, I think PLA is a good base standard for general purpose. Is there a reason, I’m not aware of, that would make it better in PLA? Thanks in advance!. If I wanted a part for a high stress application, and carbon fiber nylon PLA: strong but brittle, particularly at layer lines. I think PETG is actually more dense 1. 045, this one is 0. Tbh, PLA+ is reasonably durable if it’s not subject to extreme temperatures or large loads. On the other hand, PLA is still considered better in terms of ease of use, printing performance, and sustainability. htpla vs petg Just got my hands on a Black Friday order of snow white raptor pla from makergeeks and was wanting to reprint my prusa parts in a dif colour. Sometimes it is something else. People probably use PLA because it's more popular. 6 days ago · This article will analyze the differences between PLA and PETG in detail from these aspects to help you make more accurate material selection based on your specific printing needs. I've got a glass bed, which I'm covering with painter's tape to protect, and it's a little annoying to change after each print, successful or not. One thing I've noticed is that clear PLA tends to have a yellowish tint that clear PETG lacks. A good "in-between" material is PETG. So now seemed as good as any time. Super glue, no matter how good, just isn't good enough for PETG as it doesn't bond with it. Depending on your setup you should be using 10-30% parts cooling fan and no more if you care about strength. Since there's going to be more demand for it, the manufacturers do more to keep up the supply. " I think it's mostly a marketing gimmick. I would like to place the AMS on the printer and do multicolor prints. I did not realize it at first. As a PLA The main reason PLA is still so common is environmental factors. It's really that easy. Material Definition of PLA and PETG. ASA - With properties similar to ABS but improved UV and weather resistance, ASA’s creep resistance is generally comparable to that of PETG. I generally use PLA since I try to avoid petroleum based plastics like PETG. Like you've already mentioned, anything PLA will be less temperature- and UV-resistant as well. Nothing worked because I was using PLA temps, speeds, feeds, etc. I know PLA is worse for outside projects due to its UV stability, but if it’s primed and finished correctly would I see that much of a change in UV performance between the 2 materials. See full list on 3dinsider. - Pressure advance value is significantly lower than other PETG, both Bambu and Overture came in at about 0. I use PETG for functional parts where it may be left in a car on a hot sunny day, outdoors, furniture pieces, etc. That being said, I've printed blasters made of both PETG and PLA+ and both have held up well. Typically it's made from a corn starch base and is biodegradable. And with PLA you have a wide range of filaments with extreme different capabilities. So if you're just doing a lot of test prints PLA is way more environmentally friendly than PETG PETG doesn't like cooling. MPCNC needs rigid parts, more than tough (impact resistant) parts. That's due to the carbon fibers making it extremely ridged while PLA is a fairly weak material. Put the time in on the front end by really dialing in your profiles and it will print just as easily (and cleanly) as PLA. Esun PLA + has the best color depth IMO but is EXTREMELY weak in comparison to Sunlu PLA + and Meta after being printed and sitting around gathering moisture for a few weeks or months. Yes, a little more stringy than PLA + but feels just as strong with even better finish quality and color depth of Sunlu's PLA +. AzureFilm vs Devil Design vs Fiberlogy (PLA and PETG) Like title says, who used what and which one is best for PLA and PETG? I can't speak for their PLA as I don't use PLA but their PETG is cheap and prints really nice, just at a lower temp than atomic/prusament. Jan 19, 2023 · While PLA plus (PLA+) is considerably stronger than standard PLA, PETG is still stronger than PLA plus, can withstand higher temperatures, and is resistant to chemicals, water, and fatigue, making it the better choice in most cases. CF PLA . I mostly print with PLA, sometimes PETG. In direct strength test PETG is better than PLA. I ended up getting 9 rolls during the sale and every one was perfect out of the pack but the colors and white were very muted. I also set a script to turn the cooling down to 50% halfway through to see if cooling has an effect on PLA and also to see if it fails or not. PLA is better than PETG in easy to print PETG is better than PLA in creep resistance PETG is better than PLA in fatigue resistance That's my experience. I think you are right about the temp! Might be hard to turn the heat up any more than it is because of the bed. Jul 10, 2022 · In summary, PETG fares better than PLA in terms of mechanical strength, suitability for outdoor use, and thermal stability. I went back to printing PLA after a couple of rolls of PETG and I kind of wonder why I bothered. I will be printing this model and I'm wondering if PLA or PETG would be better for this project. I am working on printing a sword to hang on my wall purely for decorative purposes. Here, enthusiasts, hobbyists, and professionals gather to discuss, troubleshoot, and explore everything related to 3D printing with the Ender 3. I whould however be concerned that printing PETG on textured PEI can leave a microscopic residue of PETG on the plate that might compromise its ability to print PLA later when enough of it accumulates. As a PLA As much as I like PETG, PLA is still the "dominant" filament - especially for beginners. denser, larger frames like a plastikov or an ar15 are fine for PETG. Only real problem I see is that you need to use epoxy to glue pieces together. PETG is fantastic, but terrible for pistol frames. My plan is to prime, finish and topcoat the print - but I can’t decide to go with PLA or PETG. TL;DR: Does ruby / hardened steel nozzle produce as good as results as brass nozzle for daily PLA / PETG / TPU prints ? Hello,I think it's time for me to change the original 0. But this is an incorrect definition of strong reduced to being hard. Jul 18, 2024 · The main reason to use petg instead of pla (for me at least) is in order: equal price, heat resistance (more than once I got heat deformed pla when I didn't expect it to), less creep (put a static load on pla and it will slowly deform, has more implications than you think), UV resistance and quiet printing (less fan needed) Jul 20, 2024 · Hello, I’m a little scared by the show up of the PETG-HF as new filament when PETG Basic is discontinued. Once I started using the correct temps and all, everything went fine. Although not perfectly transparent, the added info of relative size shape and color of part helps find it from visual scan. I've used PETG for many of my mechanical parts and it holds up surprisingly well. Interestingly, the PETG mini (gray) came out much better than the PLA (white) mini. The profiles are all in PLA, but it seems like it would be better in PETG (stronger, more durable, can be cleaned with higher temperature water). One point, though - I question the value of "PLA+. Some brands are better than others and PETG quality even from same brand can differ a lot. PLA is great for rapid prototypes and just high speed printing in general, PETG tends to need slower print speeds but it has much much much better mechanical properties and better resistance to UV, water, chemicals, etc. 27g/cc vs PLA 1. I also printed many vase mode clear PETG bins for lots of m2/m3/… nuts/bolts. PLA, which is made from plant-based materials, is more rigid and brittle, but prints with excellent detail. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. I think the texturing helps in leveraging off the PETG print when it cools which helps counteract the strong bonding. Things that will stay indoors and in a reasonably temperature controlled environment. PETG is better than PLA in temperature resistance. 03 or so, closer to PLA than it is PETG - It likes cooling, almost as much as PLA, most PETG I've printed will have weak layers if there's too much cooling but this one doesn't seem to care, I use 60% aux fan with 80-90 PLA is often seen as a low quality / low tech material, but it depends on the use case. PLA looks better, prints more easily and is cheaper. PETG is basically the same plastic thats used in water bottles. It’s such a small difference it hasn’t caused a great deal of concern in my mind. For a clamp I would definitely recommend PETG over carbon fiber PLA because the PETG will be able to withstand a lot more stress before breaking. PETG is excellent for these bins- strong, durable, flexible, but rigid enough. As a PLA Jul 18, 2024 · The main reason to use petg instead of pla (for me at least) is in order: equal price, heat resistance (more than once I got heat deformed pla when I didn't expect it to), less creep (put a static load on pla and it will slowly deform, has more implications than you think), UV resistance and quiet printing (less fan needed) Jul 20, 2024 · Hello, I’m a little scared by the show up of the PETG-HF as new filament when PETG Basic is discontinued. Posted by u/bigchungus_69420_ - 1 vote and no comments I've gotten some PETG and got a mostly successful Benchy printed (Good Lord, the stringing on this stuff), but I'm nowhere near where I am with PLA. Jul 18, 2024 · The main reason to use petg instead of pla (for me at least) is in order: equal price, heat resistance (more than once I got heat deformed pla when I didn't expect it to), less creep (put a static load on pla and it will slowly deform, has more implications than you think), UV resistance and quiet printing (less fan needed) Jul 20, 2024 · Hello, I’m a little scared by the show up of the PETG-HF as new filament when PETG Basic is discontinued. 4 brass nozzle of the mk3s+ and we'd very much like to try various materials like wood and metal filaments. Slightly hard to see because the PLA is white, but definitely more detailed with the PETG. i always print at the top of the They're using PETG and mine is PLA but initially I was wondering if the same kind of parameters would work. :V I have noticed that their "white" PETG was more like "milk-jug white" than "proper white", and that their black PLA was more like a near-opaque dark brown, but in general I didn't really notice the black having a lack of color unless it's printed very thin, and as for dimensional accuracy, my rolls have always Resin is nasty stuff, BUT for your purposes the best choice if you're willing to worth with it. CF PETG vs. Less degradation over time. PLA and PETG are my go-to, and both have their place. Kind of surprised. I could get a perfect first layer every time. Sometimes it is PETG, sometimes it is TPU. Welcome to the Ender 3 community, a specialized subreddit for all users of the Ender 3 3D printer. It has a lower melting point and is biodegradable. PLA is stronger than PETG. PLA is popular because it's a great material with high reliability and very low health risks. However, the clarity of PETG is highly dependent on its printing temperature (higher = clearer) which in turn can be a problem for PTFE-lined hotends. PETG: a bit less strong, but far more durable. Fdm printers just won't print at that scale well out of the box, and honestly will probably never print a mini as well as a resin printer. Under 25C, PLA is one of not THE most rigid filament you can find, bested only by prohibitively expensive and difficult to print materials. i find holes print clean and PETG doesn't bond to it's own supports. In general when going from PLA to PETG: If you're not using an all metal hotend; try decreasing speed with 50% and increase temperature to ~230C (dont go too high or you'll damage the PTFE liner in the hotend), decrease retraction distance. And it seems like nylon and polycarbonate can’t be effectively printed at the temperatures achievable by an ender 3 pro. PETG-HF is not the successor of PETG Basic, right? Apr 25, 2024 · PETG - Provides a good balance between ease of use and mechanical properties, with moderate creep resistance, better than PLA but below Nylon. Never used PETG before. But it's also among the trickier materials to print with. PETG is great for printing large objects like helmets. If environment is hot, PLA is shit. For me cheap pla is much much weaker than cheap petg at roughly the same price but print quality is a bit worse but it could be my setting is not dialed in support is Almont imposible to remove stringing are carzy(my filament is wet lol) but layer adhesion is much much better than pla and it less brittle too. Also degraded over time. For the people that want to know what this is, It is a drill for the potting industry, if you have a plant in a pot and need a bigger pot they use something like this to do it automatically. The best PLA i used is extrudr PLA. I like PLA for display or shelf models and trinkets or gifts. com Jan 3, 2025 · PETG is a strong, flexible and chemically resistant plastic that can withstand higher temperatures. I think that most users will get the same satisfaction out of ordinary PLA and spend 20% less for it. From my limited research it seems like PLA is too biodegradable to withstand outdoor use. I must be lucky then, I've had no issues with Amazon Basics Premium PLA, either. In layer adhesion. I have actually already printed the same sword but a different model before, but it didn't have the Please post the parameters you set such as temp, speed, retraction etc. If you have parts cooling fan running too fast then PETG becomes weak and brittle. PLA (Polylactic Acid): a biodegradable thermoplastic derived from renewable resources like corn starch or sugarcane. It is durable and has a glossy surface. If you need a really rigid part that isn't going to see heat or UV, PLA has been better for me than PETG. But it's never Bad to have a spool on hand :) Nylon is pretty good when it comes to gears and/or some heat resistance. Same goes for "fill" materials, where you can get PETG with filler materials but it's far, far easier to get filled PLAs. Not as good as nylon, but considering how much easier PETG is to print it's well worth it. Of the two, PETG seems to be more reliable and less prone to shrinkage. I’m currently designing and prototyping birdhouses. The reason PETG is annoying me is i’m building an adapter for a dehydrator, and given the temps it’s subject to I HAVE to use PETG on a very thin detailed part. PETG is a great material when PLA doesn't cut it, and vice versa. PETG is better than PLA in wear resistance. The Raptor line of pla is supposed to be HTPLA so u was wondering if its good enough for printer parts over petg once anealed Welcome to the Ender 3 community, a specialized subreddit for all users of the Ender 3 3D printer. It won't be swung around or used as an actual sword in any means. That said, I love PETG. With carbon fiber PLA both the filament in the spool and the printed pieces are more likely to break. Right now I'm printing with 0% infill and it looks at little better. Companies generally don’t say what their additive is either. the firearms i have printed from PETG come out fantastic and didn't need supports in areas that the same print in PLA+ did. The biggest being that it is quite a bit more flexible than PLA (again, not sure vs ABS). So afaik, this leaves me with ABS and PETG. Much stronger, up to twice. 25g/cc. It also helps to know when to use PETG, and when PLA is fine. Jan 3, 2025 · PETG is a strong, flexible and chemically resistant plastic that can withstand higher temperatures. Print whatever works for you. I would like to ask you guys before buying the X1 with AMD and maybe be disappointed. I believe PETG is a bit more forgiving and flexible, while PLA+ has the slightly better impact resistance and strength, but I could be wrong. If you define "strong" as hard for sure PLA is stronger than PETG. My general rule of thumb, if it’s meant to last a long time, or if it’s something that I will be using all the time, PETG is better. Well, I needed some more filament and bought some PETG by mistake. qxcmjxt zdhctb xtef pli gmue emheg aqu fevjad sqflh odtdomc vjdzx sgwukz rlruh cwyvu xmizf